Teachers assess children’s learning and development through observing them while they work and play. Linda Mitchell . In Ministry of Education (Ed.). In a recent literature scan for the Ministry of Education (2015), the writers have called for “a reinstatement of professional development in assessment for all teachers and in all early childhood settings” (p. 54). environment: "live", Peter Reynolds CEO Early Childhood Council . Twitter This article draws on a qualitative ethnographic study of one early childhood setting. There are even ECE templates in Māori. About the Early Learning Action Plan. Podmore, V., & Carr, M. (1999). Early childhood education lays a foundation for future learning and educational success, and research shows that culturally responsive teaching and assessment are strong themes for that future success. New Zealand has had a national early childhood curriculum since 1995, and government-funded access to early education for three and four-year olds since 2007. Although there are a number of resources available to support teachers’ assessment practices, such as. Responses from the parent questionnaire completed as part of the setting selfreview process, in addition to teacher reflection, revealed that there was often a lengthy period of time between the teachers writing a learning story and parents reading the learning story. Checklists were based on developmental norms and, twice a year within the centre I worked at, teachers completed a checklist for each child enrolled at the centre. At the core of social constructionism is the belief that knowledge is constructed through interaction and social processes (Burr, 1995; Lock & Strong, 2010). 2008 Effective assessment of children in ECE involves noticing, recognising and responding to their learning. In her earlier work, Carr (2001) also recognises that “qualitative and interpretive methods using narrative methods – learning stories – are timeconsuming,” highlighting that teachers “have had to develop ways in which these more story-like methods can be manageable” (p. 18). As part of a centre led self-review process, a questionnaire was completed by parents, and many parents felt that more ‘formal’ opportunities to discuss children’s learning within the setting would be desirable. During one staff meeting, teachers explicitly discussed these tensions and proposed the possibility of getting rid of the lists and focusing on writing stories about anything they noticed as significant learning. Nearly all New Zealand children attend early learning services before starting school. Although many authors have praised the learning story framework (Dunn, 2004; Feltham, 2005; Hatherly & Sands, 2002; Mitchell & New Zealand Council for Educational, 2008; Nyland & Alfayez, 2012; Reisman, 2011), not all are convinced of the effectiveness of learning stories; Blaiklock (2008, 2010), for example, voices concerns about this assessment framework. Whilst there is no one ‘right’ way, stories generally aim to reflect the values and beliefs of the particular learning community. The planning will link to the document of desirable of objectives (DOPs), Te … Moss, P., Dillon, J., & Statham, J. Based on deficits identified in checklists, teaching strategies were developed, aiming to fill the gaps in children’s knowledge and learning (Carr, 2001). Over time, I have considered this further and began to ask: what are some of the issues and tensions teachers were grappling with, in terms of assessment? This article has discussed some of the practical strategies teachers were using to include multiple perspectives within documented assessment; it has also highlighted some of the struggles and tensions teachers faced as they went about completing assessment documentation. In J. Nuttall (Ed. In basic terms, this involves teachers noticing what children are involved in, recognising some of the learning, and responding to what they recognise. Early Childhood Education Services Emergency Planning Guidance. Kei Tua o te Pae/Assessment for Learning: Early Childhood Exemplars is a best practice resource that will support teachers to improve the quality of their assessment … Kei Tua o Te Pae discusses a process of noticing, recognising and responding, which is often used to assess children’s learning in ECE settings (Ministry of Education, 2004a). There was a sense that reducing the amount of time between writing a story and children, parents and other teachers reading a story would help to improve communication surrounding children’s learning. Book 3. Podmore and Carr (1999) argued that the sociocultural nature of Te Whāriki meant that these assessment practices needed to change to align with the principles and strands outlined in the credit based curriculum. The focus of this thesis is a critical analysis of contemporary approaches to assessment in early childhood education in New Zealand. The Statement of Desirable Objectives and Practices in New Zealand Early Childhood Services (DOPs) outlines expectations of the standard of education and care provided by early childhood services. A qualitative research approach was used, as I aimed to develop an understanding of the meanings early childhood teachers associate with assessment (Bogdan & Biklen, 2007). Providing space in learning stories for parents to contribute. Teachers develop ways to assess children’s learning based on what works for them and their setting. Assessment within ECE is complex. return { Language helps make it possible for people to construct knowledge (Burr, 1995). window.onload = function () { The overall effectiveness of an early childhood program is dependent upon several factors: quality staff, suitable Most teachers feel confident using a variety of assessment strategies, particularly experienced teachers. However, it was not until 2001 that Carr and Wendy Lee were contracted to develop assessment exemplars (Davis, 2006). The learning story framework purposefully avoided providing a road map for how to write a learning story, so that each early childhood setting and teacher could find their own meaningful ways of assessing children’s learning. Ministry of Education. What are children learning in early childhood education in New Zealand?. Teachers said it often came down to the relationships they had with certain parents and whether teachers were organised enough to make notes that they could later draw on in non-contact times. Sociocultural approaches to education, as evident within Te Whāriki, are seen to be based on social constructionist views of knowledge (Ministry of Education, 1996). ... to bring together New Zealand and international commentary on the history, implementation, and influence of Aotearoa New Zealand’s groundbreaking early childhood curriculum framework. Assessment in New Zealand early childhood settings: A proposal to change from learning stories to learning notes. (2004a). applicationID: "RSJNLYFSEK", Teachers also felt that going through individual children’s profile books in pairs provided opportunities for discussion and debate, which were valuable to their professional practice. Through informal conservations with parents and families, one teacher felt “you can start to build those connections and hopefully bring those back when it comes to learning stories.”. May, H. (2002). The context for te whāriki: Contemporary issues of influence. Learning stories: Assessment through play. I went through initial teacher education at a time when the early childhood sector was just beginning to shift from summative forms of assessment, such as checklists and running records, to formative forms of assessment, in particular, learning stories. They also show how children, parents and whānau can contribute to this assessment and ongoing learning. Bicultural assessment: He aromatawai ahurea rua. So what is different about learning stories? There are many ways we could plan things. Speaking with colleagues about this, I discovered that I was not alone, and other teachers were struggling to make the shift in thinking and practice. (2000). //]]> Within this deficit discourse, the focus was on identifying what children could not yet do and supporting them to be able to achieve in these areas (Carr, 2001). I feel my knowledge and understanding of assessment is consistently on the move, as I explore assessment more and read about others’ perspectives. How do teachers make sense of learning assessments? The 'child in need' and 'the rich child': Discourses, constructions and practice. Programme planning is a vital sector in diverse early childhood education (ECE) service to provide quality education and care for young children. curriculum Te Whāriki (Ministry of Education, 1996) requires early childhood teachers to ‘plan activities, resources, and events which build upon and extend children’s interests’ (p.83), and a play-based, child-initiated curriculum is a common choice in NZ ECE settings. All programs in early childhood education are not equally effective in promoting the learning and development of young children. Hatherly, A., & Sands, L. (2002). Preliminary findings from this research project also suggest that more time to engage in professional discussions with other teachers can only enhance teachers’ understandings and use of formative assessment practices. })(); Ministry Bulletin for School Leaders | He Pitopito Kōrero, COVID-19 bulletins for tertiary education providers and students, Adult : child ratios in mixed-age services, Transitioning children with learning support needs, Operational Guidelines for Home-based HS22 – first aid qualification condition clause, Early Childhood Advisory Committee (ECAC), English for speakers of other languages (ESOL), Online ESOL support for students in schools, The education and disability legislation guiding our approach to learning support, Resource Teachers: Learning and Behaviour Service, Getting help for students with additional learning needs from the Specialist Teacher Outreach Service, Support for children who are blind or have low vision, Supporting children who are deaf and hard of hearing, Behaviour services to help schools and students, Te Kahu Tōī, Intensive Wraparound Service (IWS), Supporting students with speech, language and communication needs, Information for schools about teacher aide funding, National Transition Guidelines for students with additional learning needs, Entering into a Specialist Education Agreement (previously known as Section 9 Agreements), Supporting children and young people with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), In-Class Support funding for students with ongoing learning needs, Working with parents to resolve problems about learning support, Help returning young people to education from the Justice system, Archiving and disposing of school records, Enrolling students (as domestic students) who are living unlawfully in New Zealand, Apply for access to the Attendance Service Application (ASA), Legal responsibilities and national guidelines for schools on attendance, Learning support — Introduction to the sharing information guide, Sharing information about an individual without identifying them, Prohibiting gang insignia on school property, Stand-downs, suspensions, exclusions and expulsions guidelines - part 1, Stand-downs, suspensions, exclusions and expulsions guidelines - part 2, Guidelines for the provision of pastoral care, guidance and counselling, Helping children and young people while they are learning at home, Regional mentoring service for Māori and Pacific students, Children’s Act 2014 requirements for schools and kura, Preparing for emergencies, traumatic incidents, evacuations and lockdowns, Planning for an epidemic/pandemic event (quick guide), Civil defence emergency relief at schools, School Building Insurance Funding Programme, Checking your property after a major incident, Risk identification, assessment and management, Food safety for schools and kura (Food Act 2014), Guidelines for schools to develop or review a firearms policy, Police vetting for school property contractors, Injury and illness management, support and rehabilitation, CPR Training and Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) in schools, Communicable diseases in early learning services and schools: a guide to legal powers, Health and safety requirements for school and early learning service leaders, Health and Safety requirements for boards and school leaders, Implementing the Health and Safety at Work Act — a guide for early learning services, Practice framework resources for health and safety, Professional development in health and safety, Safe use and electrical equipment testing, School construction projects during COVID-19 Alert Levels, Property projects led by schools and by the Ministry, 10 Year Property Plan - information for consultants, Technical information for ICT contractors, Performance management of construction suppliers, Treaty of Waitangi Settlements Property Redress Programme, Roles and responsibilities in property management, Private schools' registration and management, Public private partnerships to build schools, Integrating schools into the state system, Historic heritage features on school sites, Modular buildings for new spaces at schools, Learning support and specialist school related facilities' property entitlement, Accidents and incidents on school transport, Information for Directly Resourced schools, Eligibility for school transport assistance, Resourcing — operational funding and staffing entitlements, Secondary Tertiary Alignment Resource (STAR), Resource teacher learning and behaviour (RTLB) support funding, Special purpose units (activity centres, teen parent units, other), School funding for Programmes for Students (PfS), Non-teaching staff – funding for settlement of collective agreements, International Student Wellbeing Strategy 2019/20 funding, Furniture and equipment funding for state schools, Furniture and equipment for integrated schools, Maintenance funding for integrated schools, Accommodation for Learning Support Coordinators, Schools' annual report (annual financial statement), Model liquidation statement — Kiwi Park Primary School, Related parties — state-integrated schools, Risk Management Scheme — contents and liability insurance, What Families/Whānau Need To Know About School/Kura Donations, Examples of what Families/Whānau Need To Know About School/Kura Donations, Requirements for Boards of Trustees of Decile 1-7 Schools and Kura Choosing To Opt In To the Donations Scheme, Examples for Decile 1-7 Schools/Kura opting in to the Donations Scheme, Requirements for Decile 8-10 Schools/Kura and Schools/Kura Not Opting In to the Donations Scheme, Examples for Decile 8-10 Schools/Kura and Schools/Kura Not Opting In to the Donations Scheme, Registration, practising certificates and LATs, Te Aho o Te Kura Pounamu Early Childhood teachers, Police vetting for schools and kura Māori, Scholarships, awards and funding for people working in schools, Te Aho o te Kura Pounamu specialist and support staff, Special residential school non-teaching staff, Kaiārahi i te Reo, therapists, ATSSD and special education assistants, Special terms or conditions (concurrence), Superannuation for principals and teachers, Digital technology safe use guide for schools, Digital Technology: Safe and responsible use in schools, Sharing data from your Student Management Systems, Property data and asset management systems, TELA+ digital devices for teachers and principals, Enabling home internet access for your community, Protect your school from cyber-attacks and cyber security breaches, Ministry newsletters and education related websites, More information on setting term dates, holidays and closing days, Religious instruction guidelines for primary and intermediate schools, Media enquiries – Information for schools, All-of-Government (AoG) office supplies contract, Pacific Education Foundation Scholarships (PEF), Employment outcomes for tertiary education graduates for different tertiary providers, Education (Pastoral Care of Domestic Tertiary Students) Code of Practice, Pastoral Care for domestic tertiary students Q&A, Services for Tertiary Education Organisations (STEO), Classifications of courses and qualifications, Paying the Export Education Levy - SDR providers, Paying the Export Education Levy - non-funded PTEs, Mission Statement for the Centres of Research Excellence (CoREs), Tertiary education institution name change criteria, Supplying goods and services (procurement), The Prime Minister's Education Excellence Awards, Senior Advisors: Refugee and Migrant Support contact details, Auckland office accessible carpark and access, Complaints options independent of the Ministry, Consultation on the Export Education Levy (EEL) 2019, Consultation on compulsory student services fees, Consulting on the Annual Maximum Fee Movement rate for 2020, Havelock North and surrounding area — Future schooling provision, Action Plan for Pacific Education 2020-2030, Ka Hikitia – Ka Hāpaitia | Te Rautaki Mātauranga Māori (te reo Māori), Ka Hikitia – Ka Hāpaitia | The Māori Education Strategy (English), Te Aho Ngārahu – fostering te reo Māori through localised curriculum resources, Tau Mai Te Reo | The Māori Language in Education Strategy (English), Tau Mai Te Reo | Te Rautaki mā te Reo Māori i roto i te Mātauranga (te reo Māori), Summary of Te Hurihanganui: Community Implementation, Te Rautaki Rawa Kura – The School Property Strategy 2030, The Statement of National Education and Learning Priorities (NELP) and the Tertiary Education Strategy (TES), NZ Sign Language videos: The Statement of National Education and Learning Priorities (NELP) and the Tertiary Education Strategy (TES), Ka Ora, Ka Ako | healthy school lunches programme, Background information about the Learning Support Update, A new model for delivering learning support, Practical guidance and tools to help implement the Learning Support Delivery Model, Digital Technologies and Hangarau Matihiko learning, More information on the curriculum change, Holidays Act Compliance — schools payroll, Holidays Act compliance — Ministry payroll, Data for Wellbeing programme (was Integrated Education Data – iEd), Rebuilding Christchurch Schools 2013-2022, How we're using vacant school sites in Christchurch, Christchurch Schools Rebuild Programme Newsletters, Improving Classrooms in Small or Remote Schools, Privacy Act 2020 – resources for schools and early learning services, The Statement of National Education and Learning Priorities (NELP) and the Tertiary Education Strate, Rebuild at Christchurch Girls High School, Extending eligibility to student support to people who were affected by the Christchurch mosques terror attack, Massey University Early Literacy Research Project, Education (Early Childhood Services) Amendment Regulations 2019, Secondary School Attendance in Auckland under Alert Level 3, Responses to Official Information Act requests, Transparency statement about information gathering for regulatory compliance purposes, Education and Training Act 2020: Regulatory Impact Assessments and Supplementary Analysis Report, The Education and Training Act 2020: Parents, whānau and students, The Education and Training Act 2020: Information for Boards, The Education and Training Act 2020: Early Learning me ngā Kōhanga Reo, The Education and Training Act 2020: Te Tiriti o Waitangi, The Education and Training Act 2020: Information for the disability sector, The Education and Training Act 2020: Information for principals and teachers, The Education and Training Act 2020: Tertiary Education and Training, Education and Training Act 2020: Improving planning and reporting, Education and Training Act 2020: Prohibiting the provision of NCEA offshore, Education and Training Act 2020: Strengthening Te Kura's Governance Arrangements, Education (Pastoral Care) Amendment Act 2019, Education (Vocational Education and Training Reform) Amendment Act 2020, Education (School Donations) Amendment Act 2019, Regulations to better support international students, The National Administration Guidelines (NAGs), Briefing documents for Incoming Ministers, Summary of Vote Education and Vote Tertiary Education initiatives, Vote Education and Vote Tertiary Education initiatives Budget 2020 - five year funding breakdown, Supporting Māori learners, Kōhanga Reo, and revitalising te reo Māori, Trades and Apprenticeships Training Package, Adult and Community Education - a modern approach to night classes, Paving the way for a fully qualified early learning workforce, Further investment to move NCEA exams online, Summary of Education Portfolio Budget 2019 initiatives, Education Portfolio Initiatives Budget 2019 - Five year funding breakdown, Government introduces donations scheme for Decile 1-7 schools, Te Kōhanga Reo Contingency Fund - Budget 2019, Government invests to bolster teacher supply, Increased learning support for pre-schoolers, Increased support for Deaf and hard-of-hearing students, and assistive technology, New funding for Pacific Education through Budget 19, Vote Education Summary of Initiatives - Budget 2018, Vote Tertiary Education Summary of Initiatives - Budget 2018. The early learning sector includes kindergartens, ngā kōhanga reo, playcentres, education and care services (such as childcare centres or preschools), home-based ECE services, hospital-based services, playgroups, ngā puna kōhungahunga, and Pacific Island playgroups. This has led me to my current research, which focuses on investigating teachers’ understandings and practices of assessment. Vol 38.2, Australasian Journal of Early Childhood. Teachers really valued any opportunities they had together to discuss children’s learning. London: Paul Chapman Publishing. Nonetheless, due to time - 13 - constraints, teachers often felt pressure to produce learning stories. Within the next staff meeting, a teacher questioned how multiple perspectives were working, and, in response, one teacher articulated: “this is my biggest frustration, how, when and how to make it manageable with all the children.” As part of teachers’ attempts to manage multiple perspectives and get it right, each teacher discussed a range of ways how they currently access multiple perspectives, as well as some strategies they would like to try. Teachers talked about their desire to make multiple perspectives work, where the voices of children, parents, as well as, at times, wider family/whānau members and other teachers, were clearly evident within practice in general and documented assessments. A formal parents’ evening to discuss children’s learning and assessment procedures within this setting was deemed one way teachers could ensure that all reasonable efforts were being made to keep parents informed. These include professional studies, development and learning, and early years’ pedagogy. Demands on teachers’ time. In this context, Regulation 43 Curriculum standard states that every licensed service provider must, (b) make all reasonable efforts to ensure that the service provider collaborates with the parents and, where appropriate, the family or whānau of the enrolled children in relation to the learning and development of, and decision making about, those children. What follows is a discussion of some of the strategies identified by the teachers. It was noted that children’s interest sheets were generally pasted into the front of children’s profile books; however, sending these to parents on a more regular basis may help teachers gain a greater depth of knowledge about children’s changing interests. holistic view of learning and development. Although there is no prescribed form of assessment within ECE settings, the sector generally now employs narrative forms of assessment, often in the form of learning stories (Education Review Office, 2013).